Cook County Record

Wednesday, January 29, 2020

NorthShore says antitrust class action, accusing of overcharges, has no qualified representative


By Dan Churney | Oct 16, 2018


NorthShore University Health System wants a judge to strip the class-action status from an antitrust lawsuit against the hospital chain, which alleges NorthShore’s acquisition of a suburban hospital rubbed out competition and jacked up prices for patients, saying the sole remaining class representative has no standing to push the suit, because he suffered no injury.

 On Oct. 10 in Chicago federal court, Evanston-based NorthShore filed a motion that asked Judge Edmond Chang to decertify the suit’s class action status, which had been granted in December 2013. 

 NorthShore, which already had hospitals in Evanston and Glenbrook, merged in 2000 with Highland Park Hospital. In 2007, the Federal Trade Commission ruled the addition of Highland Park breached antitrust law by eliminating competition in that region, allowing NorthShore to sharply raise prices.

 NorthShore has since also acquired Skokie Hospital.

 Soon after the FTC ruling in 2007, the suit was lodged against NorthShore, with plaintiffs alleging patients and insurers were forced to pay more than they would have if market competition had been maintained. This alleged price increase came despite NorthShore’s promise the merger would benefit consumers, managed care organizations and communities served by the hospitals, the suit said. 

 NorthShore has unsuccessfully tried several times to have the case thrown out, but has succeeded in having several class representative eliminated, because they were not directly affected by NorthShore’s alleged wrongdoing.

 NorthShore is now aiming at the last remaining class representative, David Freedman, alleging he is “fatally flawed” like the others.

 Freedman was hit by a car in April 2013 and treated at NorthShore’s hospitals in Highland Park and Evanston, but said the charges were too high, according to court papers. However, Freedman negotiated a discount for part of the bill that “more than wiped out any alleged overcharge,” according to NorthShore. 

As a consequence, Freedman suffered no alleged injury to serve as a representative of the class or to even have a claim, in NorthShore’s view. Without Freedman having a claim, the class has no claim, NorthShore asserted.

NorthShore presented other arguments why Freedman is not a qualified representative.

Freedman sued the party he alleged hit him with the car, which ended in settlement. Freedman’s attorneys in that suit, Kupets & DeCaro, of Chicago, negotiated another discount with NorthShore and themselves paid the remainder of Freedman’s bill, according to court papers. Kupets & DeCaro recouped the payment through its cut of Freedman’s settlement. As a result, part of Freedman’s bill was covered by another party, further undercutting any alleged injury Freedman suffered.

In addition, Freedman’s insurer failed to renegotiate with NorthShore pursuant to the FTC’s 2008 order that entitled insurers to such renegotiation of bills, NorthShore claimed.

The second discount arranged through and paid by Kupets & DeCaro also disqualifies Freedman on grounds he is not typical of most class members, who only experienced one discount and directly paid NorthShore, NorthShore argued.  

Plaintiffs included Amit Berkowitz, Steven J. Messner, Henry W. Lahmeyer and Painters District Council No. 30 Health and Welfare Fund.

Plaintiffs are represented by the Chicago firms of Wolf Haldenstein Adler Freeman & Herz, Miller Law and Grant Eisenhofer, as well as by lawyers David Balto, of Washington, D.C., and Mary Jane Fait, of Chicago.

Freedman is representing himself.

NorthShore is defended by Winston & Strawn, of Chicago.

Want to get notified whenever we write about any of these organizations ?

Sign-up Next time we write about any of these organizations, we'll email you a link to the story. You may edit your settings or unsubscribe at any time.

Organizations in this Story

Miller Law LLCWolf Haldenstein Adler Freeman and Herz LLCWinston and Strawn LLPNorthshore University HealthsystemU.S. District Court for the Northern District of IllinoisGrant & Eisenhofer

More News